Cosmo blinked after the kids disappeared, chest still tight. Rook’s words—sharp, loud, unflinching—echoed over the arcade noise in his head. He swallowed hard, gripping the striker like it was an anchor.
When Rook turned back with that softer grin, the knot in Cosmo’s throat unraveled a little. He ducked his head, glasses slipping down his nose, voice quiet. “Thanks. For… y’know. Not letting them get away with that.”
His ears burned hotter as Rook’s words replayed: you look ten times hotter when you’re leaning over this table. Cosmo bit his lip, fumbling for something—anything—that didn’t sound like a squeak.
“You can’t just—say stuff like that. Not after—” He cut himself off, shaking his head with a tiny laugh. “You’re seriously going to give me a heart attack before the night’s over.”
Still, when the puck slid toward him, he shifted, blocking it clumsily but successful this time. A tiny spark of pride flared in his chest.
He glanced up, cheeks flaming, but the corner of his mouth tugged into a shy smile. “Alright, fine. But if I’m terrible, you’re not allowed to tell anyone, got it?”
He tapped the puck back, lighter than he meant to, but his eyes were steady on Rook’s now, gratitude and nerves tangled together.
--Fin--
Rook let the cocky grin linger, then softened it just for Cosmo.
“still waiting on that ‘why,’ stargazer,” he teased, tapping the puck so gently it moseyed across the table like it had all night. “until then, i’ll try not to melt you.”
He shifted into coach mode without the condescension—chin tilt, quick demo with the striker. “Tiny wrist flick. Keep your striker a little off the goal line—gives you room to react. And bank shots are your friends.”
Then he played… badly. Convincingly badly.
He over-sold a few lunges, clipped the post with a theatrical wince, and “oops”-ed a clean miss that let the puck drift home. When Cosmo blocked him, Rook’s eyes lit like he’d just watched a championship save.
“There he is,” he said, low and proud. “That’s my menace.”
Every point Cosmo scored, Rook made it feel earned—upping the speed a hair, then dialing it back, feeding him lanes, letting confidence creep back into Cosmo’s shoulders. Neon washed over them; the table hummed; Rook’s laughter stayed easy and close.
9–9.
Rook lined up, met Cosmo’s eyes, and smirked. “House rule: winner claims the other guy’s bag… and one photo for the trophy wall.”
He flicked a lazy bank that Cosmo read perfectly, snapped it back past Rook’s “too slow” dive, and the puck thunked into the back of the goal.
Victory tone. Lights. Rook threw his hands up like he’d planned the parade.
“CHAMPION!” He caught Cosmo’s wrist and lifted it high, then bowed over dramatically. “Teach me, Professor.”
He leaned on the rail, grin all teeth and sunshine. “And, for the record? I’m totally telling everyone you destroyed me.” Beat. “By ‘everyone’ I mean my camera roll. And maybe my grandma. She loves a prodigy.”
He slid a fresh quarter across the glass with a knuckle. “Rematch… after a celebratory cookie? Tax rate’s tripled for winners.” A wink, easier than breathing. “Can’t help it—confidence looks stupid hot on you.”
-fin-
Cosmo’s face went nuclear at the wrist-lifted victory pose, his laugh coming out half-snort, half-disbelieving giggle. “Professor? Oh my god, you’re insufferable.” He pulled his hand back and buried it in his hoodie pocket, though the grin tugging at his mouth betrayed him.
“And the cookie tax? At this rate you’re gonna eat through Bubbe’s entire kitchen,” he muttered, shaking his head. “She’s gonna start charging me interest for supplying you.”
Still, when Rook slid the quarter across the table, Cosmo picked it up, twirling it nervously between his fingers. The compliment—confidence looks stupid hot on you—burned hotter than any neon overhead. His ears went scarlet, and he ducked his head with a groan.
“You seriously need a filter,” he said, voice muffled but not without warmth. “But… I guess I don’t mind feeding your cookie addiction. Just… don’t tell Bubbe you’ve tripled the rate. She’ll put me on kitchen duty for the rest of the semester.”
He flicked the puck into play again, biting his lip to hide the grin sneaking up. “Loser buys the next round of fries. And spoiler alert—it’s not gonna be me this time.”
--Fin--
Rook bit back a grin so hard it almost hurt. There you are.
“Insufferable? absolutely,” he said, rolling his shoulders like a prizefighter and tapping the mallet to the rail twice. “And for the record, my filter is factory-defective. Return policy expired.”
He leaned in over the table, voice dropping conspiratorially. “Tell Bubbe I’m willing to pay in labor. Dishes, peeling potatoes, taste-testing cookies—whatever gets me a line of credit.”
The puck zipped; Rook met it with an easy block, then sent it back just off-center—quick enough to feel legit, soft enough to give Cosmo a lane. “There you go, stargazer,” he coached, playful. “Ride the rail—yup, like that.”
Cosmo scored. Rook whooped like he’d lost the Stanley Cup on purpose. “OH NOOO, MY PRIDE,” he groaned, head thrown back, then flashed him a wicked smile. “Do it again.”
He kept it competitive—smart angles, lazy power—always leaving just a breath of space where Cosmo could thread the shot. And every time Cosmo nailed one, Rook hyped him like a stadium crowd: knuckles drumming the glass, a quick tap to Cosmo’s wrist when he returned the puck, eyes shining like this was the only galaxy in the room.
Match point. Rook let the puck kiss the rim of his own goal, then clack—game. He flung his hands up, wrists crossed in mock surrender. “Professor Cosmo: 1. Menace Rook: 0. I accept my fries-buying fate.”
He slid the mallet aside, leaning on the table, voice soft around the edges. “Confidence looks good on you. Keep it.”
Then, lighter: “Victory lap to the fry counter? Or—hear me out—photo booth. Winner gets to choose the pose, loser carries the cookie bag… at triple tax.” He winked. “I’ll make room in the ledger.”
-fin-
Cosmo tried—really tried—to glare at him over the rail, but the way Rook threw his head back and groaned like he’d just lost an Olympic medal
**** him. A laugh burst out before he could stop it, bright and unguarded, and he ducked his head immediately, ears flaming.
“You’re ridiculous,” he muttered, though the little grin tugging at his mouth betrayed him completely. He pushed his glasses up with one hand, still flushed from the hype. “Nobody cheers this much when they’re losing.”
But Rook’s praise—confidence looks good on you—landed right in his chest, and suddenly Cosmo was fidgeting with the striker, biting his lip like he could swallow the blush away. “…Thanks,” he mumbled, softer, but it carried.
When the options hit the air—fry counter or photo booth—Cosmo groaned, burying his face in his hoodie sleeve. “You and your cookie tax are out of control.” He peeked up, shy but shining. “But… photo booth. Fries after. I’m not carrying that bag everywhere while you gloat.”
He tried for a smirk but it came out crooked, boyish, nervous. “Fair warning though—I’m vetoing any pose where you make me look like your sidekick. Equal billing only.”
He shoved the striker back into the slot and tugged at his ponytail, cheeks still glowing. “So yeah. Photo booth. But only if you promise not to steal another kiss in front of a camera this time.”
The way his voice
**** halfway through made the warning less threatening and more like an open dare.
-fin
Rook slid an arm along the rail and flashed a helpless, theatrical groan—then broke into a grin so bright it was practically neon.
“Then I guess I’m nobody,” he said, tipping two fingers to his temple in a lazy salute. “Equal billing, Professor. Cross my heart.”
He laced their fingers for exactly three steps, then let go to tug back the photo-booth curtain, feeding in quarters like he owned the place. “Okay, high art only,” he murmured, thumbing through frames until he found one with 8-bit stars and a tiny rocket. “Stargazer theme. Obviously.”
The countdown lit.
4 — Rook dropped into the frame with his best troublemaker smirk, chin tipped down, eyes up, knuckles at his jaw like a wanted poster.
3 — He popped both hands into ridiculous peace signs, tongue out, committing to the bit.
2— He turned and pressed a quick, warm kiss to Cosmo’s cheek just as the flash went off, then snapped back forward, biting his grin and failing miserably.
1 — final light blinked. Rook wheezed a laugh, shoulders shaking, one hand covering his mouth as he pointed at the empty air where the camera had just captured it.
When the strip spat out, he snatched it, fanning it like a winning hand. He tapped the third panel with an utterly unrepentant sparkle in his eyes. He slid one copy into his wallet—front slot, no hesitation—then hooked a thumb toward the fry counter. “C’mon, stargazer. Victory fries. And, uh… cookie tax still applies. I don’t make the rules—I just handsomely enforce them.”
-fin-
Cosmo was already red by the time Rook laced their fingers for those three steps, but the kiss in the booth—with the camera flash catching it—was nuclear. He froze mid-frame, eyes wide, ears burning so hot he was certain they could power the arcade’s neon.
When Rook fanned the photo strip like a prize, Cosmo buried his face in both hands with a strangled groan. “Rook!” His voice
****, muffled through his palms. “You said no camera kisses!”
He peeked between his fingers anyway—big mistake. The third panel was right there. His blush went critical, racing from his cheeks all the way down his neck.
“You’re impossible,” he mumbled, half into his hoodie sleeve, trying and failing to smother the grin breaking through. “Absolutely, infuriatingly impossible.”
He tugged his glasses up with shaky fingers, then snatched the second copy of the strip like it was contraband, stuffing it into his pocket with a muttered, “Mine.” His ears glowed crimson.
As Rook gestured toward the fry counter, Cosmo shook his head, still flustered beyond repair. “Victory fries, cookie taxes, photo evidence of my imminent death by embarrassment—” He huffed a laugh, cheeks burning. “You’re gonna kill me before our second date at this rate.”
But the way his eyes shone—bright and nervous and happy all at once—gave him away completely.
They claimed a booth with a view of the arcade floor, fries steaming between them. Rook lounged back like he owned the place, legs stretched out under the table, plucking one fry at a time with lazy precision.
Cosmo was still crimson from the photo booth fiasco, the strip of pictures hidden deep in his pocket like smuggled treasure. He tried to focus on his soda, on the hum of the games, on anything but the way Rook looked when he tipped his head back and laughed. But then Rook dangled a fry between two fingers, smirk sharp as ever and Cosmo couldn't seem to help himself. He leaned across the table, heartbeat rattling, and closed his lips around the fry before Rook could even blink.
The moment his lips brushed the fry, Cosmo’s stomach flipped like he’d just cannonballed off a diving board. He sat back down so fast his chair squeaked against the tile, ears blazing.
He tried to focus on chewing, on swallowing, on literally anything that wasn’t the fact he’d just leaned across the table and—basically kissed Rook’s fingers.
His hoodie sleeve was halfway over his knuckles by the time he dared to speak, voice cracking in the middle. “Th-there. Tax paid.”
The words tumbled out quick, like a defense. He tugged harder at the sleeve, shrinking into the fabric, but the tiniest grin broke through anyway—nervous and crooked, but real.
“Still… still want your cookie?” he muttered, eyes darting to the fries like they might save him from combusting.
And just like that, the blush that had started in the photo booth went full nova all over again, leaving Cosmo grinning helplessly into his soda.
--Fin--
Rook actually froze—just a hitch, a blink—then color climbed his cheekbones. The grin that followed was slow and feral.
He lifted the two fingers Cosmo’s mouth had brushed and, with maddening calm, tasted the salt off them. “Bold,” he murmured, eyes never leaving Cosmo’s. “I like bold, stargazer.”
The fry basket slid across the table toward Cosmo with a knuckle-nudge. Under the table, Rook’s boot found Cosmo’s ankle—light pressure, a steady touch that said he wasn’t playing it off. “Tax paid,” he conceded, voice dipping, “but interest is a thing.”
Cosmo’s question hung there and Rook’s smile sharpened. “Do I still want my cookie?” He leaned in, elbows on the table, those freshly kissed fingers tapping once between them. “Always. But I’m patient.” A beat. “I’ll collect—one bite at a time.”
He sat back, legs stretched, gaze warm and reckless. “Your move, professor.”
-fin-
Cosmo swore the ground might as well open up and swallow him whole. The second Rook’s tongue brushed those fingers, heat shot straight through his veins and landed squarely in his face.
His jaw dropped. Did he just—?
Cosmo yanked his hoodie sleeve up over his mouth, muffling a half-groan, half-squeak. “You—you can’t just—!” His words came out strangled, tripping over themselves as he tried not to combust on the spot.
The steady press of Rook’s boot against his ankle only made it worse— grounding and dizzying all at once. Cosmo curled his toes in his sneaker, unable to stop the nervous little flutter in his stomach.
He peeked over the edge of his sleeve, cheeks crimson, eyes wide. “You’re seriously gonna kill me before dessert at this rate.”
Then, softer, shy but honest: “…And you know it.”
He shoved a fry in his mouth too fast, glaring down at the basket like it had betrayed him, but the crooked, helpless smile tugging at his lips gave him away completely.
Cosmo nursed the last of his soda, trying to will the blush out of his cheeks. It didn’t work—especially not with Rook’s boot still pressed to his ankle like a casual claim.
The fries had dwindled to crumbs, the arcade buzz dimming as the night wore on. Cosmo flicked his phone awake just to check the time—and winced.
“Uh…” He tugged at his hoodie sleeve, reluctant. “I should probably… head home soon. Bubbe’ll kill me if I roll in after ten. She’s patient, but not that patient.”
He tried to play it casual, but the weight in his chest said otherwise. He didn’t want the night to end—the neon glow, the laughter, the way Rook’s eyes never seemed to leave him.
Cosmo pushed his glasses up, giving Rook a crooked, sheepish grin. “This was… really good. Like… ridiculously good. Fries, Galaga, photo evidence of my total humiliation, all of it.”
His cheeks heated again, but he pushed through it, voice dropping softer. “I don’t really… want it to end. But if I don’t go, Bubbe’s liable to come storm the arcade herself.”
He slid the cookie bag across the table, smirking faintly despite the blush. “Peace offering. For the triple tax.”
----
Rook’s grin sharpened when Cosmo went pink again; he let the boot at Cosmo’s ankle press once—warm, reassuring—then eased off and sat back like a cat who’d just knocked something off a shelf on purpose.
He accepted the bag with mock ceremony. “Tribute for the triple tax? Accepted,” he said, tucking it into his jacket like contraband. “For the record, that fry move was lethal. Consider me critically wounded… in a very survivable way.”
At the curfew talk, he lifted both hands, palms out. “No casualties before dessert, promise. And I plan on living long enough for date three.”
He stood, swept the empty basket into the trash with one hand, then leaned on the table to snag his tokens and receipt. “I’ll walk you home. Hands where Bubbe can see ’em,” he added, winking. “I’ll even carry the cookies so I don’t get arrested for intent to snack.”
He slung his jacket over his shoulder, then offered a hand to help him up—steady, not pushy. “Tomorrow: date three. Stargazing for my stargazer. Blanket, thermos, terrible constellation puns. I’ll ask before any… upgrades.”
On the way out, he paused by the photo booth and tapped his pocket with a little, smug tilt of his mouth. “I’m framing shot three. That smile? Criminal.”
At the door, he pulled it open with a small bow. “C’mon, Professor. Let’s get you home before Bubbe declares a statewide manhunt. Then you text me you’re in safe, and I’ll send you a star playlist to pregame tomorrow.”
-fin-
Cosmo buried his face in his hoodie sleeve when Rook called the fry move lethal, muttering, “You’re the worst,” though the smile tugging at his mouth ruined the attempt at indignation.
“Date three, huh?” His voice
**** halfway, sending his ears scarlet again. He shoved his glasses up, glancing at Rook sidelong. “…You just like making me blush, admit it.”
Still, he let Rook tug him up, his hand lingering longer than he meant to before he grabbed his bike from the rack. They fell into step together—Cosmo walking it slow instead of riding, so he didn’t have to split the moment too fast. Rook’s board wheels rattled softly along the pavement, the sound weirdly comforting in the quiet night.
Cosmo kept sneaking glances at him, cheeks pink, hoodie string twisted between nervous fingers. “You know… Bubbe’s gonna have my head if I come home looking like this,” he mumbled. “She’ll take one look and know I—” He broke off, ears burning hotter. “—that we had fun.”
The porch light of his house glowed at the end of the street. Cosmo’s pulse spiked. He stopped by the curb, fiddling with his handlebars like they were suddenly the most interesting thing in the universe.
“Thanks for walking me back,” he said, soft but sincere. “And… for tonight.” His cheeks flamed darker as he shifted, heart hammering. “I—uh—”
Before he could lose his nerve, he leaned quick across the bike and pressed the fastest kiss to Rook’s cheek—barely a brush, hot and clumsy. Then he was back, fumbling for his garage keys with ears blazing crimson.
“Okaybye!” he blurted in one word, shoving the bike toward the garage. The door rattled open, and he all but rushed inside, hoodie pulled tight, face on fire.
But under it all, he was grinning so wide his cheeks hurt.
--Fin--
Rook didn’t move for a heartbeat—just stood on the sidewalk, fingers touching the spot Cosmo’s lips had landed like he’d been stamped. Then the grin hit, full force, and he blew out a quiet, disbelieving laugh.
“Night, stargazer,” he murmured to the closed garage, not loud enough to get Bubbe’s attention.
He kicked off on his board, cookie bag tucked into his hoodie pocket, and let the downhill carry him. The city felt different—edges softer, neon warmer. He veered toward his usual hideout: the abandoned rooftop with the clean skyline and the busted-up HVAC that doubled as a seat. He dropped onto the metal,
**** the cookie bag, and studied the view like he was scouting a stage.
Yeah. Date three. Up here. Blanket, thermos, constellations he still half-remembered. He could already hear Cosmo’s laugh in the dark.
On the way down he left a quick throw—small star cluster, a sly R tucked in the tail—then pushed home. Dad was waiting, not mad about curfew, just chores. Rook didn’t argue. He scrubbed, folded, took the trash out, all on autopilot with one hand drifting to his cheek every few minutes like a reflex.
By the time he collapsed at two, the photo-booth strip was tucked in his wallet and the rooftop plan was a lock.
Morning found him at school with shadows under his eyes and that same stupid smile he couldn’t shake. He bumped his locker shut with a hip, thumb brushing the edge of the kiss-mark memory, and thought: worth it.
-fin-
Cosmo barely got his sneakers off before he was ambushed in the kitchen.
His mom sat at the table, glasses perched low on her nose as she sorted through bills. Bubbe stood at the stove, humming some old Polish tune while stirring a pot that smelled like heaven. Both pairs of eyes snapped to him the second he walked in, and Cosmo froze like a deer in headlights.
“Well?” his mom prompted, folding her arms. “You were out late.”
Bubbe’s smile was softer but just as sharp. “How was your date, moy złoty?” my golden one.
Heat rushed up Cosmo’s neck so fast he nearly tripped over his own words. “I—uh—it was good. Really good.” His voice
****, and he cleared his throat, fumbling with the strap of his bag. “We just… talked, and, um, hung out. That’s all.”
Bubbe’s knowing hum said she didn’t believe him for a second.
“And this boy,” his mom asked, one brow arched, “is he being respectful? Kind?”
“Yes! Totally,” Cosmo blurted, waving both hands like a defense attorney. “He’s—uh—he’s great. Really. We’re gonna go stargazing next time. Nothing crazy, promise.”
That earned him a tiny, approving smile from Bubbe and a slow nod from his mom. “Alright,” she said finally, going back to her bills. “Just be careful. We trust you.”
Cosmo’s ears still burned, but a relieved breath slipped out as he slung his bag down by the table.
---
Later that night, Cosmo packed quietly, humming under his breath while his Bubbe’s soap opera murmured in the background. He checked his notebook twice, slid goggles and gloves into the side pocket of his backpack, then tucked a carefully labeled sample kit beside them. His experiment supplies were ready.
When he finally crawled into bed, his phone sat charging on the nightstand. He couldn’t stop smiling at the thought of Rook on that rooftop, blanket and thermos and constellations. Date three, he thought, pulse quickening, before sleep pulled him under.
Morning came too fast.
Cosmo scrambled into jeans and a hoodie, nearly tripping over his own feet as he shoved books into his pack. He skidded into the kitchen, hair sticking up like static, just as Bubbe was sealing his lunch in a neat brown paper bag.
“Tell Rook,” she said with a sly glint in her eye, “if he wants more cookies, he must help bake the next batch.”
Cosmo froze mid-reach, face igniting scarlet. “B-Bubbe!” he squeaked, mortified. Then, quieter, “I’ll… I’ll tell him.”
She chuckled, pressing the bag into his hands. “There’s extra food inside. Share with him,” she added warmly.
Cosmo swallowed the lump in his throat and nodded, leaning in for a rushed hug. “Thanks, Bubbe.”
“Go, go,” she shooed, patting his cheek. “Don’t miss your bus!”
-------
The roll to school was quiet; Nathan’s wheels hummed beside his and said more than either of them felt like saying. Inside, the noise sharpened—gossip like broken glass. Rook heard Nathan’s name first, then Alastor’s, then his own and Asher’s floating on the edges, and something mean in him went very, very still.
He planted himself near Nathan’s locker anyway—just a shadow with a board and a don’t-try-it stare—until a different kind of brightness cut through the hall.
Cosmo.
Bubbe, cookies, brisket, baking invitations—Cosmo tumbled all of it out like confetti, and Rook felt his jaw unclench without permission.
He tipped his chin, grin sliding in. “Tell Bubbe I can wield a whisk and a wooden spoon like a pro. I’m in.”
Then, lower—just for Cosmo—“And yeah, date three’s already set. Tonight, if you’re up for it.” A quick, conspiratorial flick of his eyes toward the roofline outside. “Bring that stargazer brain. I’ll bring the view.”
He let his knuckles brush Cosmo’s backpack in passing—quick, secret—and then shot a look back down the hall, gaze hardening as another ugly whisper rippled past.
“Lunch is ours,” he added, voice easy again but edged with intent. “Brisket diplomacy at noon. After school, we bounce.”
The grin came back for Cosmo alone. “Try not to make me fall in love with your grandmother’s cooking in one day.”
And then he settled again at Nathan’s six, casual as a lamppost, the kind that happens to light up trouble before it gets too close.
-fin-